Accidents Involving Passenger Fatalities
U. S. Commuters (Part 135) 1982 - Present

The NTSB wishes to make clear to all users of the following list of accidents that the information it contains cannot, by itself, be used to compare the safety either of operators or of aircraft types. Airlines that have operated the greatest numbers of flights and flight hours could be expected to have suffered the greatest number of fatal-to-passenger accidents (assuming that such accidents are random events, and not the result of some systematic deficiency). Similarly, the most used aircraft types would tend to be involved in such accidents more than lesser used types. The NTSB also cautions the user to bear in mind when attempting to compare today's airline system to prior years that airline activity (and hence exposure to risk) has risen by more than 35% from the first year depicted to the last.


                                                                                                         
                                                                                                         Passengers
                                                                                                        ------------
Date            Location                Operator (DBA)                  Aircraft Type                   Fatal   Surv
----------      --------                --------------                  -------------                   -----   ----
02/21/1982      PROVIDENCE, RI          PILGRIM AIRLINES                DEHAVILLAND DHC-6                 1        9
12/09/1982      NEAR KLAWOCK, AK        TYEE AIRLINES, INC.             DEHAVILLAND DHC-2                 7        0
08/17/1983      PEACH SPRINGS, AZ       LAS VEGAS AIRLINES              PIPER PA-31-350                   9        0
03/05/1984      CUMBERLAND, MD          CUMBERLAND AIRLINES             PIPER PA-31                       2        0
07/21/1984      TAU,MANUA               ISL SOUTH PACIFIC ISLAND        DEHAVILLAND DHC-6-300             1       10
 
08/02/1984      VIEQUES, PR             VIEQUES AIR LINK, INC. BRITTEN  NORMAN BN-2A ISLANDER             8        0
08/24/1984      SAN LUIS OBISPO, CA     WINGS WEST AIRLINES, INC.       BEECH C-99                       13        0
09/07/1984      NAPLES, FL              PROVINCETOWNBOSTON AIRLINES     CESSNA 402C                       1        4
12/06/1984      JACKSONVILLE, FL        PROVINCETOWNBOSTON AIRLINES     EMBRAER BANDEIRANTE EMB-110P1    11        0
12/17/1984      BAINBRIDGE, NY          SUSQUEHANNA AIRLINES, INC.      PIPER PA-23-250                   2        0
 
02/04/1985      SOLDOTNA, AK            NORTH PACIFIC AIRLINES          BEECH 65-A80                      7        0
02/06/1985      ALTUS, OK               ALTUS AIRLINE, INC.             CESSNA 402B                       1        0
04/26/1985      NEW YORK, NY            NEW YORK HELICOPTERS            AEROSPATIALE SA360C DAUPHIN       1        5
08/25/1985      AUBURN, ME              BAR HARBOR AIRLINES             BEECH 99                          6        0
09/23/1985      GROTTOES, VA            HENSON AIRLINES                 BEECH B99                        12        0 

11/01/1985      BETHEL, AK              HERMENS AIR, INC.               CESSNA 208                        1        2
03/13/1986      ALPENA, MI              SIMMONS AIRLINES                EMBRAER EMB-110P1                 2        5
10/28/1986      ST. CROIX, VI           VIRGIN ISLAND SEAPLANE SHUTTLE  GRUMMAN G-73                      1       12
01/15/1987      KEARNS, UT              SKY WEST AIRLINES INC. (SKY     SWEARINGEN SA-226TC               6        0 
                                        WEST AIRLINES/WESTERN EXPR) 
03/04/1987      ROMULUS, MI             FISHER BROTHERS AVIATION INC.   CASA C-212-CC                     7        9 
                                        (NORTHWEST AIRLINK)

04/01/1987      ANCHORAGE, AK           WILBUR'S FLIGHT OPERATIONS      CESSNA 402                        1        0
                                        (WILBUR'S INC.)
11/23/1987      HOMER, AK               RYAN AIR SERVICE, INC.          BEECH 1900C                      16        3 
12/23/1987      KENAI, AK               SOUTH CENTRAL AIR, INC.         PIPER PA-31-350                   5        2 
12/23/1987      MAUNALOA, HI            PANORAMA AIR TOURS (PANORAMA    PIPER PA-31-350                   7        0 
                                        AIR TOURS) 
01/19/1988      BAYFIELD, CO            TRANS COLORADO AIRLINES (TRANS  FAIRCHILD SA-227-AC               7        8 
                                        COLORADO) 

02/19/1988      CARY, NC                AVAIR, INC. (AMERICAN EAGLE)    FAIRCHILD SA-227-AC              10        0
04/19/1989      PELICAN, AK             CHANNEL FLYING SERVICE          DEHAVILLAND DHC-2                 1        0
07/30/1989      HAINES, AK              SKAGWAY AIR SERVICE             PIPER PA-32-301                   2        2
10/28/1989      HALAWA,MOLOKAI, HI      ALOHA ISLANDAIR DE HAVILLAND    DHC-6-300                        18        0
12/26/1989      PASCO, WA               NPA/UNITED EXPRESS (UNITED      BRITISH AEROSPACE BAE-3101        4        0 
                                        EXPRESS) 

09/03/1990      KALTAG, AK              FRONTIER FLYING SERVICE         PIPER PA-31-325                   3        6
02/01/1991      LOS ANGELES, CA         SKYWEST AIRLINES, INC.          FAIRCHILD SA-227-AC              10        0 
04/05/1991      BRUNSWICK, GA           ATLANTIC SOUTHEAST AIRLINES     EMBRAER EMB-120RT                20        0
07/10/1991      BIRMINGHAM, AL          L'EXPRESS AIRLINES, INC.        BEECH C99                        12        1
08/20/1991      KETCHIKAN, AK           TEMSCO HELICOPTERS, INC.        PILATUS BRITTEN-NORMAN            3        0 
                                        (TEMSCO AIRLINES)               BN-2A-26 ISLANDER 

09/11/1991      EAGLE LAKE, TX          CONTINENTAL EXPRESS             EMBRAER 120                      11        0
12/10/1991      TEMPLE BAR, AZ          LAS VEGAS AIRLINES, INC.        PIPER PA-31-350                   4        0
01/03/1992      GABRIELS, NY            COMMUTAIR (USAIR EXPRESS)       BEECH 1900C                       1        1 
01/23/1992      CLEWISTON, FL           AIR SUNSHINE INC.               CESSNA 402C                       1        0 
06/07/1992      MAYAGUEZ, PR            EXECUTIVE AIR CHARTER, INC.     CASA 212                          3        0 
                                        (AMERICAN EAGLE) 

06/08/1992      ANNISTON, AL            GP EXPRESS AIRLINES, INC.       BEECH C99                         2        2 
10/27/1992      SAIPAN, MP              PACIFIC ISLAND AVIATION, INC.   CESSNA 310R                       2        0 
10/31/1992      GRAND JUNCTION, CO      ALPINE AVIATION (ALPINE AIR)    PIPER PA-42                       2        0  
11/08/1992      KIANA, AK               BAKER AVIATION INC.             CESSNA 402C                       2        0 
04/03/1993      NOME, AK                RYAN AIR SERVICE, INC           CESSNA 207                        1        0 

07/12/1993      LAS VEGAS, NV           AIR NEVADA AIRLINES             CESSNA 402C                       2        0 
12/01/1993      HIBBING, MN             EXPRESS AIRLINES II, INC.       JETSTREAM BA-3100                16        0 
                                        (NORTHWEST AIRLINK) 
01/07/1994      COLUMBUS, OH            ATLANTIC COAST AIRLINES         JETSTREAM 4101                    2        3 
                                        (UNITED EXPRESS) 
12/13/1994      MORRISVILLE, NC         FLAGSHIP AIRLINES               BAE JETSTREAM 3201               15        5
                                        (AMERICAN EAGLE)
08/21/1995      CARROLLTON, GA          ATLANTIC SOUTHEAST AIRLINES     EMBRAER EMB-120RT                 7       19 
                                        (DELTA CONNECTOR)

11/19/1996      QUINCY, IL              GREAT LAKES AVIATION            BEECH 1900                       10        0
                                        (UNITED EXPRESS)
01/09/1997      IDA, MI                 COMAIR                          EMBRAER 120                      26        0
02/08/1997      ST. THOMAS, VI          AIR SUNSHINE                    CESSNA 402C                       2        2
04/10/1997      WAINWRIGHT, AK          HAGELAND AVIATION               CESSNA 208B                       4        0
06/27/1997      NOME, AK                OLSON AIR SERVICE               CESSNA 207                        1        0

11/08/1997      BARROW, AK              HAGELAND AVIATION SERVICES      CESSNA 208B                       7        0
09/05/1999      WESTERLY, RI            NEW ENGLAND AIRLINES            PIPER PA-32-260                   2        2
12/07/1999      BETHEL, AK              GRANT AVIATION                  CESSNA 207                        5        0
09/18/2000      NUIQSUT, AK             CAPE SMYTHE AIR SERVICE         PIPER PA-31T3                     4        5
10/03/2001      DECATUR ISLAND, WA      WEST ISLE AIR                   CESSNA 172N                       2        0

10/10/2001      DILLINGHAM, AK          PENINSULA AIRWAYS               CESSNA 208                        9        0
07/13/2003      TREASURE CAY, BAHAMAS   AIR SUNSHINE                    CESSNA 402C                       2        7
12/14/2006      PORT HEIDEN, AK         PENINSULA AIRWAYS               PIPER PA-32-301                   1        0



The NTSB wishes to make clear to all users of the preceding list of accidents that the information it contains cannot, by itself, be used to compare the safety either of operators or of aircraft types. Airlines that have operated the greatest numbers of flights and flight hours could be expected to have suffered the greatest number of fatal-to-passenger accidents (assuming that such accidents are random events, and not the result of some systematic deficiency). Similarly, the most used aircraft types would tend to be involved in such accidents more than lesser used types. The NTSB also cautions the user to bear in mind when attempting to compare today's airline system to prior years that airline activity (and hence exposure to risk) has risen by more than 35% from the first year depicted to the last.